Controversy grows when facts are scarce and communication is limited. The situation between Falak and Rosemary is no different. Here’s a closer look at one of the most talked-about controversies in PUBG Mobile history.
In This Article, you will find:
- How Controversy Started?
- How Falak Responded?
- How Fans Reacted?
- Player Profiles & Roads to Glory
- 4T Falak vs AE Rosemary Stats Comparison
- How Community Reacted? Who supported Who?
- How Rosemary has to eat his words
- From Rivals to Brothers
- Toxic Drama vs. Healthy Rivalry: The Impact on Esports Athletes
How Controversy Started?
During a live stream in February 2026, one of Falak’s fans compared him to Rosemary and said, “4T Falak is better than you.” Without hesitation, Rosemary responded:
“I am up here, and Falak is down there. I can beat him anywhere.”
That single remark quickly spread through the community and sparked one of the biggest player debates in PUBG Mobile esports. What began as a casual comparison soon turned into a heated rivalry and a months-long fan war.
How Falak Responded?
Falak reacted with some frustration but remained respectful, calling Rosemary’s behavior childish:
I don’t understand this childish mindset. I haven’t said anything to anyone, yet they make comparisons themselves and cry about it themselve.
I mean, there are players like Top, Dok, Nolbu, Sylas, Carriho, and many more who have delivered much bigger performances. They are global MVPs and Champions. If they wanted, they could also come out and say that they are the best and that this so-called player is not even close to them in terms of achievements and performances. But they don’t have a childish mindset, and they are not immature. They know how to respect every player. They stay humble, and that’s why we respect them and call them the best.
How Fans Reacted?
Fans of both players flooded the internet to defend their favorite star. Look at how they responded: Rosemary’s fans defending his statement:
He was fed up with being spammed with Falak’s name on his YouTube live. by tr4um3r3i (Indonesian handle on Instagram)
Falak’s Fans judging Rosemary’s claim:
Overconfidence…Lets see this year’s ultimate battle. by rookee_x10 (Instagram Handle)
Indian fans of rosemary
Only Rosemary. by ig_akash_1816 (Instagram handle) supporting him.
Rosemary fir bhi better hai by upnishhbandral8 (Instagram), considering him above falak.
And some fans have reacted on an achievement basis:
The Only Problem is India and pakistani fans. they are so obsessed with them that they can’t appreciate others. Why the hell they need to go on rosemary stream and ask him about falak. I know falak is brilliant player but rosemary is different because he have PMSL Trophies and falak didn’t won yet so kindly please stop this pathetic behaviour. by uchiha_obito_da_6 (An Insatgram Handle)
Player Profiles & Roads to Glory
When Did AE Rosemary Start Playing? Career & Achievements
Rosemary, an Indonesian player whose real name is Juventino Ryan Jeremy Rolos, is 23 years old. He began his esports career in PUBG Mobile and joined Supply Bang in 2021. After a brief stint with the team, he departed and started earning significant prize money in 2022 when he joined GPX.
Before the end of that year, he joined Alter Ego Ares and has remained with the organization ever since. His career earnings are estimated at approximately $142,129.
Rosemary’s defining career milestone remains his victory at the PMSL SEA Fall 2023, cementing his legendary status alongside an incredible record of 18 individual MVP titles, spanning prestigious FMVPs, Week 2 or 3 MVPs, and Grand Finals MVP accolades across different events. The massive global appeal of his playstyle was on full display during the 2025 PMWC, where team Alter Ego reached an astounding peak viewership of 1,388,918 concurrent spectators, anchoring the organization’s status as a top-tier powerhouse, with total career earnings sitting at $633,295 to this day. And now, Alter Ego is again on the rise, qualifying for major events.
4T Falak’s Journey to the 2026 PMGO Championship
Falak Sher is a Pakistani PUBG Mobile prodigy from Dadu, a city in Sindh, Pakistan. At just 19 years old, he has already established himself as one of the country’s most accomplished players. According to Liquipedia, he began his professional career in 2022 with 4Thieves, spent time with other teams, and later founded his own organization, 4Thrives, in 2024.
The biggest achievements of his career came in 2026, when he led 4Thrives to victory at PMGO Season 1 and followed it up by winning PMGO South Asia Season 2. The team also represented Pakistan on the global stage, becoming the country’s only participant at the Esports World Cup. They secured an impressive 7th-place finish in 2025 and improved to 6th place in 2026, competing against some of the world’s strongest PUBG Mobile teams.
His approximate total earnings are $142,774. He has been an MVPs in different tournaments 11 times.
Keep Reading: PUBG Mobile 4.6 Bloodline Awakening: Best Meta Loadouts Guide
4T Falak vs AE Rosemary Stats Comparison
To be honest, Rosemary’s claim does not fully reflect reality, as Rosemary has played significantly more matches than Falak. However, whenever Falak has competed, he has consistently delivered strong performances. This table clearly highlights that difference and provides the proper context for comparing their achievements.
| Performance Metric | 4T Falak | AE Rosemary |
|---|---|---|
| Matches Played | 144 | 182 |
| Total Eliminations | 225 | 312 |
| Kill-Death (KD) Ratio | 1.56 | 1.71 |
| Total Damage Dealt | 52,079 | 78,004 |
(A, S tier events of PMSL Spring, PMWC, PMSL Fall, PMGC stats of 2025) from @Gaming Portal.
How Community Reacted? Who supported Who?
The7WG said after 4thrives winning of PMGO S1:
Anybody that still thinks that Falak is down here and Rosemary is here, that is completely gone and trust me. I used to be one of those people that’d be like, ‘Okay, Falak needs to do a lot more.’ Today, the performance out of 4Thrives as a team, the performance out of Falak, it’s now the opposite.
And PUBGM Caster Maxman agreed with him. While casters and analysts HotJukes and John Allen supported Rosemary.
How Rosemary has to eat his words
The controversy eventually came to an unexpected end. While many fans continued to support Rosemary’s stance, those arguments lost momentum when Falak lifted the PMGO Season 1 trophy, in Jakarta, Indonesia.
During a post-match interview, 7WG asked Falak:
“What do you have to say now about the debate over who is above and who is below?”
Falak responded confidently:
“I don’t need to say anything. This trophy proves everything. It shows who is up here and who is down there.”
His statement carried extra weight as Alter Ego failed to qualify for several major events, while Falak had just secured one of the biggest titles in the scene. For many viewers, that moment effectively put the debate to rest.
Keep Reading: Pakistan’s 4Thrives Performance at the PUBG Mobile World Cup 2026
Falak 1/10 gameplay remark
After Alter Ego failed to qualify for PMPL, Falak made the now-famous “1/10” remark about the team. The comment quickly became one of the most talked-about moments in the community, sparking debates among fans and players alike.
Looking back, the situation serves as a reminder that success is never permanent in esports. No player or team stays on top forever. Championships and recognition belong to those who continue to improve, adapt, and perform when it matters most. In the end, the ever-changing nature of competition proves that yesterday’s success guarantees nothing for tomorrow.
From Rivals to Brothers, Finally
As Falak continued to climb the ranks, qualify for major tournaments, and establish himself among the best, Alter Ego’s results began to decline. Eventually, Rosemary and Falak put their differences aside and shook hands, bringing an end to the months-long fan war. What had once been one of the scene’s biggest rivalries concluded with mutual respect, allowing both players and their supporters to move on.
Toxic Drama vs. Healthy Rivalry: The Impact on Esports Athletes
These controversies in every field work like a magnet for viewership. People who didn’t know Falak searched for him to learn more about him, and vice versa. There are different aspects to every controversy.
First, it makes players famous and increases competition because it becomes a matter of pride and respect. It stays healthy up to this point.
Second, it builds pressure and creates burnout, and if players fail to succeed, it can lead to embarrassment and heartbreak.
Third, fans often go overboard and start attacking the opposing player’s personality. So, it is healthy only as long as it doesn’t become toxic. Luckily, this controversy ended on a healthy note for both players.
